The Butcher's Cellar

Refined Dining

What makes it fun

Ready for a night of refined dining with your sweetheart? The Butcher's Cellar is the place. The vibe at The Butcher's Cellar is refined with upscale sophistication. The menu features hearty steaks, delicious chops, and succulent seafood options. The food menu is sure to impress and the cocktail menu certainly follows suite with both timeless classics as well as innovative libations. Get gussied up and head to Butcher's Cellar for a fine dining experience that will make your taste buds dance.

Google Reviews

4.5

Based on 151 reviews

Aaron

05:41 23 Feb 25

Overall the experience was okay, but we spent $300. So okay does not justify the cost. We got the 1000 layer potatoes and bao buns for appetizers, and the bao buns were good, potatoes were bland. Ordered a sushi roll, and by the time we were half way done they finally brought soy sauce out, but the container was empty so had to wait on the new one to be brought out. Main issue was my wife ordered the fillet medium rare, came out well done. She didn’t want to wait on it to be remade, so I shared my ribeye with her. When I brought it to the servers attention, I felt that he was annoyed more than anything. So instead of any effort made by him or the management to make this right, we paid for a $48 steak that was not what we asked for. From there the service went downhill. We will not be eating here again, as the food quality for a steakhouse charging these prices, as well as the overall service experience does not justify the cost.

Kait (transcend_ lilbit)

05:22 23 Feb 25

We booked a 5:15 dinner reservation for a Saturday night - which we were able to secure the same week of, great! This was our first time to dine-in and we were greeted politely and sat right away. The decor is eclectic and I did like it, some pieces on the wall seemed random but I think if it was in the “butcher’s cellar” anything could be down there. We were sat at a table and asked if we could get a booth, the hostess said she would check. She came back and said that unfortunately all tables are booked but next time if we want a booth we should request one in our reservation….. this was strange because does that mean all the booths were spoken for thru reservation? That was not a big deal, just an interesting response. We were greeted by our server casually. We ordered 2 appetizers: the 1000 layer potato - it was good and it’s what you would expect. But not for $17. I think it’s because of the fish roe, which IMO is out of place. The other one was the wagyu boa buns - very good. Our server recommended them when we asked what appetizer must we try. For our mains: my husband ordered a 16 oz ribeye medium rare and crispy frites and I ordered the torched and pressed and the 6 oz filet medium rare. The torched and pressed (sushi) was pretty tasty. It was a fun play on a deconstructed sushi roll. After we ate about half, the server brought out soy sauce and ginger. We wish that would have been brought out at the same time with the dish as the soy sauce’s acidity helped pair with the sweetness, but it was not a dealbreaker. My husbands ribeye was cooked medium rare (leaning more rare in some parts) and my filet was over-cooked (I ordered medium rare and instead it was slightly pink). We told our server “the filet is overcooked and we just wanted you to know”. Our server could have handled the situation better because they said maybe the kitchen mixed up the steaks and also maybe they’ll get it right next time. If this is supposed to be a steak restaurant, you would hope your steak would come out proper. Overall, it was nice to get out of the house for a date, but for the quality of food and service we received for the amount spent, it will be tough to say we will be back. For the 2 of us, it was $300 (including tip).

Skye Leamy

03:40 23 Feb 25

This place is amazing, our server Brandon was awesome and very attentive. He recommended his own personal desert other wise known as the “BP float” it was the BEST desert my mom and I have had in a long time. Great atmosphere, couldn’t be happier with this place. If you go ask for Brandon and his BP float!!

Nancy Mayo

13:42 16 Feb 25

This restaurant has a beautiful atmosphere, professional staff, and delicious food. The experience was delightful.

Dwan Childers

00:55 21 Nov 24

The food was amazing. The service at the table was a little slow, but overall everything was amazing.

massimo di campli

05:05 17 Nov 24

Went here for a birthday celebration and we couldn’t ask for a better experience.Thank you to the host/hostess team, server and cooks for an amazing experience filled with good food and good service.Cannot wait to eat here again.All the best to y’all

Mr. Froogie

01:51 17 Nov 24

You’ll eat every last bit of food on your plate. It’s that good! I had the scallops and they were delicious.

Marinel Reynolds

03:14 15 Nov 24

Wow! We already had high expectations going in since we are big fans of the Head Chefs since their Hell’s Kitchen days and after having an amazing date night last weekend, The Butcher’s Cellar far exceeded those expectations! From the moment you walk in, you are welcomed by the most gracious hosts and instantly taken into a beautiful and cozy atmosphere.The cocktails were delicious. We started with milk bread, shrimp toast, and grilled oysters.Each dish was fantastic. We wish we could have ordered more but wanted to make room for the main course. We then ordered the Steelhead Trout and Dino Rib, both melting in your mouth with each bite. We ended the night with the Key Lime Crème Brûlée and a bottle of port which was just perfection. We even got to meet Chef Alyssa who is the sweetest and most down to earth person to talk to and is truly gifted in her craft. I am so excited to try their new menu and will be visiting again very soon! This place truly is a gem for the Waco/DFW area.

Anthony Cahill

22:50 10 Nov 24

Food and service might be the best in Waco area. Highly recommend it. We've been several times and always love it. highly recommend it!!

Susanne Nemmer

17:41 19 Aug 24

The service was lacking, and it appeared more staff would help; Our server struggled with her hand-held point of sale device and it was uncomfortable for conversation and a private dining experience. Now for the food - the appetizers were incredible; Although we wanted the signature oysters as recommended by our server, only to be told after we ordered them that they had sold out of oysters the night before our visit; no free bread - but $12 for bread is insane: The food came out one plate at a time.... uggg. Two in our party ordered the Dino Rib ( 2@ $55 ea) and both stated the meat was flavorless and the mashed potatoes seemed over pureed ($13); The side requested was the Triple Cooked Fries w/malt vinegar ($11), however, we were told that this side order sold out the night before///odd???? One had the Steelhead Trout ($43) which had a great miso glaze, but it was served cold; One ordered the Tomahawk Pork Chop ($45) - which took some time because of the thickness and cut, so we can only assume that's why the fish was sitting and waiting to be served. Desserts were ordered - one blueberry/lemon tort - dry and day old; one chocolate chip cookie bake which turned out to be the highlight of the evening. All in with cocktails and our party of four, were in and out for $503. With prices like this and boasting hi-end dining experience, the Butcher's Cellar has a few things to work on. Our party agreed we might return for Happy Hour and enjoy the appetizers once more, but as for the entire meal not so much.

Matthew McGuire

17:09 18 Aug 24

Jamii was our server and knocked it out of the park. Her attentiveness was exceptional. My wife said, "I'll be having dreams about the Cheesecake Tart for weeks." I was happy to try and taste the dishes at the establishment. Shout out to Alyssa and Alejandro for bringing top-notch food to Waco/Woodway. We booked a spot around 5 p.m. and loved the space. It was my 40th birthday, and Jamii made it worthwhile. We will be back for sure.

Eric Allison

02:15 17 Aug 24

The food was uuuuuuuhhhhhhmmaaaaaaazzziiiiing!!!!

Briscos Wife

16:01 14 Aug 24

As others have mentioned, too much salt. Went there for the first time and we were excited to try a new option for fine dining. The restaurant decor and set up is inviting when you walk in. The staff and our waitress were all excellent. Sadly the filets we got were so over salted neither of us could finish them. Very disappointing as it seemed like a high quality cut of meat. SO over salted. The sides were good but I didn't understand the point of the corn ribs. They waitress said you eat them like a corn on the cob but there was really no cob to hold onto so I decided I would cut the kernels off the "rib" and that was very difficult as it is just a small sliver of the cob left which is the "rib". I finally gave up on that. Sadly, for the cost of the meal and the saltiness we won't be going back.

Richard C

20:58 13 Aug 24

Great place to eat! We went there for our Anniversary. The staff was extremely helpful in ordering. I got the lobster rolls to share and the crab cakes. My wife got the trout. All the food was great. They even took our pictures! Will definitely be back to eat.

Edwina Muriel

19:49 31 Jul 24

Everything was amazing. The service, food and ambiance was great. We drove an hour and it was all but better than worth it. I will be returning.

Garrison Fitts

01:35 31 Jul 24

Jerry Park

23:46 27 Jul 24

Excellent eclectic atmosphere, great dishes. Ask for Brandon as server. During slow time he will give you a tour. We enjoyed the lobster pasta entrée and the "Dino Rib". The rib was tender and easy off the bone. The lobster had a mild spiciness. The brussel sprouts were better than Milo's. Wagyu meatballs were good but a little firm. Highly recommend.

Alison Pankonien

17:21 23 Jul 24

The Butcher’s Cellar is a great addition to Waco for fine dining. We were greeted by a very sweet hostess, and taken to our table immediately. Our server was excellent throughout dinner, promptly giving us the extensive wine/ drink menus and answered questions regarding their delectable appetizers. We chose the grilled oysters and they were amazing! For our main course, the filet steaks were prepared and served perfectly. And finally, our 7 layer chocolate cake did not disappoint! The entire experience was exceptional!! We hope to be back soon!

Dave Chavez Jr

14:05 21 Jul 24

I've never heard of this place before until my aunt messaged me, saying we were having dinner here to celebrate my father and aunt's birthday. The experience was INCREDIBLE.The sides are family style, meaning they will get passed around, and whenever the food is ready, it immediately comes out, so some items might come out first before other items, but roughly it'll be around the same time.The atmosphere is also fantastic, with a rustic/modern clash, with glass chandeliers and granite fireplace.The restrooms are VERY clean, and very decorative with wallpaper of small little animals, and even a crow in front of the Men's Urinal.Our server, Tyler did a fantastic job with making sure we were taken care of, and answering any questions we had.I will DEFINITELY be coming back to this restaurant for dinner, either by myself or with family.

Eric Guel

00:35 30 Jun 24

What can I say? Everything was perfect. My wife and I had the most wonderful experience at The Butcher’s Cellar last night. Upon entering we were warmly greeted, ushered to our table quickly, and the service all evening was outstanding. I mean the best service we’ve ever had in Waco, period — and we’ve been in Waco for 29 years!The food? It was unreal. I’ve never felt euphoria while eating a salad … until last night. The salad with the thick cut of bacon was just unreal. And the steak was melt-in-your mouth delicious. Really everything we had was complete culinary perfection.We’ll be back. We’ll be regulars.

Hollie Jo White

00:38 04 Jun 24

From the moment I stepped through the front doors, I immediately knew how special and unique our evening would be! It was more than I could have imagined from the start. From the beautiful decor, amazing drinks, incredible service, and the "out of this world" food, we couldn't have had a better experience. Our party of 6 shared several dishes and we got to experience quite an assortment of meals, appetizers, and sides. With each bite, we were all in heaven! I even have Celiac Disease and I could enjoy the majority of all of the items on the menu. You will not be disappointed and the Chefs have worked very hard to make a very top notch menu that will be constantly changing! THANK YOU for our wonderful evening!